Jonathan Ross, the ICE agent who murdered a Minneapolis woman named Renee Good last week by shooting her three times in the head, has cemented the public view of an incipient American archetype, a persona that will play a major role in the nation’s history over the coming next few years: the MAGA civil warrior, a lethal and hate-filled authoritarian intent on destroying our democracy—and killing anyone who resists.
This persona has been radicalized into using weapons in the name of a Trump dictatorship—not just by Donald Trump, but by an entire media ecosystem funded by oligarchs who are financing this assault on a democracy they have decided is too inconvenient. This ecosystem dates back to Rush Limbaugh and continues through Fox News, as well as with even more far-right “news outlets” like Newsmax, and with social-media platforms now in the control of right-wing plutocrats like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg, not to mention mainstream corporate media now controlled by rich ideologues.
These media have ceaselessly coached their audiences into hating their fellow citizens and neighbors if they happen to prefer democracy to autocracy. The eliminationist demonization of liberals and minorities—the core of Limbaugh’s schtick—has created a massive army of right-wing extremists who see “the left” as an existential threat to their idea of America, which is an innately white-supremacist state.
The radicalized warriors hate these Others, deeply and viscerally. They don’t see them as human, but as contemptible vermin who need to be eliminated by any means. What they really want—and are constantly looking out for—is an excuse or a pretense to just begin wiping them out.
So when a mother who just dropped off her child at school—a classic “libtard” in their lexicon, one who smiles at them and says “Don’t worry, I’m not mad at you”—shows up on the scene where they are planning to arrest targets and drives her SUV into the midst of their operations, they believe they are fully justified in walking up to her driver’s side window and firing off three rounds into her face. Afterwards, of course, they call her a “fucking bitch” and high-five each other over the murder.
Of course, we know that Ross is not just an isolated instance. His fellow ICE officers not only have celebrated the killing, but now are using it as a way to threaten anyone else who dares protest them (“Haven’t you learned anything?” said one smirking ICE agent). Among the online MAGA set, the celebrations have been widespread, along with people expressing hope that the violence will soon spread so that they can shoot hundreds, thousands, maybe millions of libtards and lesbians and immigrants in the face.
This is what the opening stages of a civil war look like. And Americans are deluding themselves if they don’t want to believe that this is what is befalling them.
As we write this, ICE agents continue to spread out through Minneapolis—conducting door-to-door searches, running operations at local schools, arresting citizens at the local Target stores—and then dumping them eight miles away after determining that the arrestee is in fact a U.S. citizen—while making their visible presence felt on every street corner and every neighborhood. The city has been invaded by Trump’s personal army, and they are assaulting and killing people.
And this is just the beginning. Homeland Security boss Kristi Noem says she is sending hundreds more of her armed goons to Minneapolis. “We’re sending more officers today and tomorrow,” Noem told Fox News’ Maria Bartiromo. “They’ll arrive, there’ll be hundreds more in order to allow our ICE and our Border Patrol individuals that are working in Minneapolis to do so safely. We’re going to continue to, if they conduct violent activities against law enforcement, if they impede our operations, that’s a crime, and we will hold them accountable to those consequences.”
Other cities are next in line. Portland has already gotten a taste, with two immigrants reportedly from Venezuela shot by Border Patrol agents and forced to call for their own ambulance.
The radical right has been fantasizing about a white-supremacist civil war for ages, going back to the 1970s and finding fresh traction in the cesspit of the 21st century’s conspiracism-fueled information environment. Most of the far-right fantasies entailed seizing power through a violent revolutionary resistance rather than how it played out in the real world: through the auspices of a pathologically narcissistic billionaire all too eager to drum up racial and ethnic fears and hatreds.
Now, thanks to Trump, they’re seeing it realized. Trump, like so many dictators throughout history, has maliciously declared war on his own citizens and is now sending armies of armed MAGA thugs who trample both on the U.S. Constitution and on the lives of the people, citizens and immigrants alike, who they brutalize. He’s sending them to our own neighborhoods and arresting and murdering the people who make up our communities, targeted now not just under the flimsy rubric of immigration enforcement but because citizens believe they have not just the right but the obligation to stand up against such tyranny.
And for the first time, we’re seeing this particular conflict’s distinct shapes. Rather than involving slave-owning states, the nation is breaking down along an irrational ideological line drawn by conspiracy theories and religious authoritarianism. The armies they are sending to us are comprised of men like Jonathan Ross: MAGA warriors with a seething, murderous contempt for “the Left,” convinced that “Antifa” is the Enemy writ large, thoroughly marinated in both Alex Jones-style Bircherist conspiracism and the Fox News mentality that liberalism is innately evil and wrong, threatening to inundate white America with a brown tide. And the front lines to where they’re sending them are our neighborhoods, our schools, our workplaces.
So it’s not state vs. state—rather, it’s a lawless federal regime invading cities where his abrogation of the Constitution and the rule of law is being resisted peacefully. He’s deliberately targeting the places where nonviolent opposition has arisen spontaneously, and dismissed it by labeling it “Antifa” and “terrorism.” Noem defended the murder of Good by labeling her a “domestic terrorist.”
And of course, both Trump and Jonathan Ross are being ardently defended by the same right-wing ecosystem that gave birth to the insurrectionist army that first attacked democracy at the Capitol five years ago and is now being directed to invade our neighborhoods and business districts. Minneapolis is only the latest such city to be invaded by Trump’s goons, though the situation there is the worst we have seen so far.
The legion of MAGA devotees has predictably piled on, denouncing Cook as a “libtard” who “got what she had coming.” Right-wing trolls mocked her by posting cartoon memes celebrating her death. Other MAGA trolls announced their hope that Trump would use the violence to “let Minneapolis burn” and to round up all the immigrants by going door-to-door and deporting them on rail cars.
Over at Fox News, a former “theater kid” named David Marcus sneered that the wave of angry opposition in the streets after Good’s murder was simply “organized gangs of wine moms” who “use Antifa tactics to harass and impede ICE agents,” and claimed that such protests are not protected speech but rather a federal crime. (Of course, it’s not.) Trump himself suggested that Good deserved to die because she was “disrespectful.”

In the meantime, it’s become abundantly clear that the Trump administration—particularly the FBI, which has closed off participation in the investigation by state and local authorities, as well as DHS—will not permit a proper examination of Good’s murder and will protect Ross from consequences for his reckless killing, as well as any other ICE agent who behaves likewise. This means it is essentially open season not just on Minneapolis citizens, but residents of any other city where Trump sends his invasion force.
Ultimately, this civil war is the consequence of not only permitting Trump to escape accountability for the insurrectionist attack on democracy five years ago, but to permit him to seek re-election at all afterwards. As I wrote in The Age of Insurrection:
The January 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol, like Caesar’s crossing of the Rubicon, was both the culmination of long-building trends and a beginning, the opening salvo in an insurrectionist attack on American democracy: a declaration of their civil war.
The army of insurrectionists who followed Donald Trump’s bidding on January 6 had been cultivated and gradually assembled by Trump during his four years in office—and it has remained fanatically committed to his grand goal of displacing liberal democracy with authoritarian one-party rule since.
Afterwards, a 2021 University of Chicago Project on Security and Threats report identified an active American insurrectionist movement comprising some 21 million people. These radicalized Trump followers believe that “Use of force is justified to restore Donald J. Trump to the presidency” and that “The 2020 election was stolen, and Joe Biden is an illegitimate president.” About 63% of them believe in the Great Replacement theory, while 54% subscribe to far-right QAnon conspiracism.
It also noted that this insurrectionist movement is made up of “mainly highly competent, middle-aged American professionals,” leading the researchers to warn that their continuing radicalization “does not bode well for the 2022 midterm elections, or for that matter, the 2024 Presidential election.”
Stephen Marche observed afterwards that Americans need to shed the delusion that a civil war is a long way off. It’s here, now, in the form of that same implacable insurrectionist movement. He warned back then about the consequences of our inaction:
What the American left needs now is allegiance, not allyship. It must abandon any imagined fantasies about the sanctity of governmental institutions that long ago gave up any claim to legitimacy. Stack the supreme court, end the filibuster, make Washington DC a state, and let the dogs howl, and now, before it is too late. The moment the right takes control of institutions, they will use them to overthrow democracy in its most basic forms; they are already rushing to dissolve whatever norms stand in the way of their full empowerment.
But the nature of the MAGA civil war has been to proceed incrementally, in baby steps, like a gradually ratcheting thermometer on a pot full of frogs ready for boiling. That way, it’s harder for the media to notice, and easier for them to gaslight everyone into thinking they’re overreacting.
The path they are on, however, has become undeniable. Each increment takes us closer to an all-out violent conflagration pitting Trump’s private army against the ordinary citizens resisting his lawless tyranny. They wanted their civil war, and by God, they are determined to get it.





Was his purpose for carrying his cell phone camera as he circled his victim who was driving the automobile, so he could carefully record his overall technique,
(including intentionally, 1. putting his body in peril by standing in front of, and then, 2. shooting into, an operating motor vehicle, both of which are strictly forbidden by long-standing published official regulations), so that this video could serve as a *training video* for other ICE officers?
Indescribably great, important piece.
Thanks, David!